Why Standardized Tests?
December 10, 2020
Most students in the United States are required to take standardized tests or exit exams to graduate, but are they as productive as they may seem?. A standardized test is a timed exam which students take to measure their level of knowledge. They are used to determine a student’s entrance into college. These tests are most commonly taken during a high schooler’s junior year which is what SPASH follows. The real question is, are they worth it?
Standardized tests ,like the ACT or the SAT, show that they have not correlated with the average GPA. The GPA is the grade point average that students work on all of their high school careers. The American Educational Research Association (AERA) explains, “students that continued to college with a higher test score had a lower rate of graduation than the students who had a lower test score.” That shows how the average GPA for students gives colleges a better understanding of a student’s knowledge than the standardized tests. This means that no matter how well students do on these exams, their GPA shows a better understanding of their skills.
Many students have experienced negative effects on their mental health because of standardized tests. NYSUT , which is an organization of teachers in New York state, explains, “testing young students has increased the amount of anxiety for students. It can also lead to students crying, vomiting, etc. while taking these tests.” It can cause more harm to a student than just their education and it can also disrupt their well-being. The accuracy of that student’s test score is hard to measure. Stevens Point Area School District takes away school days from all grades just so the juniors can have their testing days. The real question is, are standardized tests worth the loss of school time?
A counselor at SPASH, who is also in charge of the standardized testing here at school, was willing to express her opinions about timed tests. Mrs. Ries commented, “standardized tests help a student understand what they are good at and the same for not good at. It could help a student with deciding what major is best for them.” She also goes against that opinion by explaining how the test is bad for a student’s future. She starts by saying “I wish they would get rid of them quite frankly.” Then she continues with “there are better ways to test a student than by a timed test.” They are not accurate to determine who a person is just by their time management.
Overall, there are very different opinions on the topic, but it is important to think about how this can waste the opportunity for students to get more school time. Also, the loss of accuracy the test holds because of the increase of mental stress and the time management that is required. Standardized tests have been used as the best way to test someone for over two hundred years. It is time to evaluate if these tests should still be required.
Sinai Yang • Dec 11, 2020 at 2:14 PM
Olivia, I found your article quite interesting because I can kinda relate to this. And I also agree with you too. The word test just seems scary because of the anxiety it gives you. But nowadays we gotta understand the process of taking timed tests that are different than what we usually did.
Isa Mahon • Dec 11, 2020 at 10:12 AM
Livi, I found it so interesting the point you made about a students GPA. The reasearch you found was really cool to learn from. It shows how standardized tests may not even play a big role in a students future and graduation. It seems like schools put such pressure on us to really get good test scores, but it seems like they really aren’t as important as teachers put them out to be.
Eli Wetter • Dec 10, 2020 at 9:29 AM
Olivia, I enjoyed reading your article mainly because I related to it so much. Your graph was a great addition to your explanation, as well. I don’t know if you meant this, but I loved the word “evaluate” in the last sentence. It sounds like instead of the tests evaluating the students, the students should evaluate the tests.